WARNING: This is a long and slightly personal post. Enter at your own risk.
The other day, a friend and colleague of mine commented on the double life I am leading. I laughed and have spent the past few days realizing how very true it is. Today I gave a talk on campus to another department on campus and we had a great conversation about food, agriculture, China, etc. They also were very interested in my career trajectory and asked about my future plans. Ugh. I hate planning my future out.
Right after college, I could have predicted what I would be doing in my life over the next decade or so. I wanted to travel and learn about life and about the world. I was on a mission by myself and for myself. I did not allow myself to be held back by getting settled--in relationships or with material things so I could pick up and go. I wanted to earn my PhD to prove to myself what I could do.
Now that I have completed my PhD, everyone in my academic life (like the people at the talk today) expect me to keep being engaged in this research. However, the more I am in an academic post-doc position, the more I question whether or not I want to be in an academic career for the rest of my life. There are a lot of amazing things my job offers that I do not get in other careers: flexibility of time, freedom to think, teach, and write as I please (within reason), intellectual conversations, lifelong learning, etc.. But it also comes with a cutthroat environment where full-time, tenure track jobs are difficult to get, pressure to publish constantly and get research grants often, and you do not have much choice over where you live. If a university offers you a job, you take it, even if it means in rural Iowa (I actually love Iowa and don't mean to offend anyone, but let's face it - life in rural Iowa is not as exciting as other places).
After more than a decade of moving from China to Maine, Colorado, back to China, and now New Jersey, I am getting antsy to settle down. The first step of this was getting a dog. Then I met D. And now I want a house (with a garden!) and maybe even a family. While there are plenty of women who have handled the pressures of academic jobs with personal life, I am not sure I want to multi-tasking. An academic job often means working 60+ hours a week during semesters and it is difficult to leave your work behind. It is really hard to separate work life from home life in an academic career. I was able to feel good about the work I was doing towards my PhD because, to some extent, I did not have many other things happening in my life.
So right now my two lives are: 1) an academic job where everyone expects me to continue doing research, which requires more travelling and publishing a lot and 2) my life with D in Colorado, my running, basically everything that I enjoy doing. I could (easily, I hope) find a job in a place where I want to be and not have to worry about trying to balance work and life and I could have a more fulfilling life. But it would not be the kind of job all the faculty I currently work with are expecting me to get. And I would probably have to give up a lot of the freedoms of an academic career.
The pressure I feel from this double life is coming from all the faculty I work with who expect me to get a permanent academic position. I took this position in NJ because it was a prestigious fellowship and all my faculty advisors in Colorado told me I should take it because it would be great for my career. Now faculty here expect me to get an equally prestigious permanent position at a university. The more I see this, I realize I am continuing down an academic path because it is what others expect of me, not myself.
So I don't know what the future holds, but the more I think about it, the more I realize I have to do what is right for me, just as I did when I was fresh out of college and joined the Peace Corps so I could travel and see the world.
I always think of that question (about if I'm doing something for me or for others) in this way: I need to put MY shoes on everyday; no one else. So I'd better get myself a good pair of shoes.
ReplyDeleteI try to listen to the feedback, but ultimately I find when I trust my gut, I'm usually right :)
I wish that for you.
Awe, thank you! It is so hard because I feel like I put all this effort into nothing if I leave the academic track, but really, I put so much into myself and that should really be what counts :)
DeleteI think it's time for a long run and a long talk. I so totally get where you are at.
ReplyDeleteFor sure! It seems most women academics have a lot to say about this topic...
DeleteWell good job braving the cold for a 20 miler! I have had those runs where you just feel yucky and then question your own ability but you DID it and that is what counts. Give yourself A LOT of credit for that!! You will have a good run and then know it was good because this last one was crappy.
ReplyDeleteSounds like you are at quite a career crossroad. You are obviously a very driven and motivated person to be where you are at today, but I love that you are truly thinking of what would be best for YOU. It's always easier said then done, but I hope you do find a balance that makes you happy.
Crossroad is a good word! I did what worked for me for so long and now I seem to have found myself in the career that my advisors suggest for me--because it has worked for them. It feels liberating to think about breaking out, even though it is scray. I think balance is a good word, too. THANK YOU, Arrienne!
DeleteGreat post. I know exactly what you mean. I have to say, now 3.5 years after choosing the housewife route, I don't regret it. There are people that don't understand and there are days when I feel the pressure, but mostly I love being able to do the things I love and explore the things I want to explore. Plus the house renovations keep me on my toes. Kudos to being brave enough to write this post. You're certainly not the only academic to feel this way!
ReplyDeleteThanks so much. Your blog is really inspiring and culminates so much about the things we don't learn in school :) I certainly know I am not the only to feel this way. Somehow putting it down and getting it out there makes it feel much more real and OK.
DeleteWhenever I'm stuck on something and need to make a decision but don't know what to do I go for a very long trail run...a very long trail run. I stop at the top of the hill and just soak up the scenery for a while. Think about what needs to get done. Then I make that long treck back.
ReplyDeleteI wish I had an answer for you. It looks like you have some decisions to make. But I'm sure you'll make the right one. Just do what's going to make you happy (now and in the long-term). I'm sure you'll still be able to sneak a good run in in the process :-)
I certainly do think well on those long trail runs. Believe me: this post was a long time in the making over plenty of long runs!
DeleteMy father, currently a dean at a major university, has been living the academic lifestyle for my entire life, and he never once slacked in the "dad" department. I think it takes an amazing person to have a family and remain career oriented, and I think you have what it takes. Just do what makes you happy.
ReplyDeleteInteresting. Good to hear. I know I have what it takes, but its a matter of it I want it all? Oh well, lots of time to think...
DeleteLife is an interesting thing...the path we think we want suddenly starts to come together and it's not quite right. But the good news is at the end of the day you can still be, do or have whatever you want :) good luck as you figure it out, I know for sure how that feels...it's scary but once you make the decision you'll feel so much better.
ReplyDeletehyou are right - making a decision is the worst part, but after that, it is so liberating!
DeleteDefinitely do what's right for you. If you don't, you might always look back and regret not following your own instincts. You can do it!
ReplyDeleteThanks! I know, one thing many people do tell me is that I have good instincts. I also just don't like the feeling that I am 'quitting' something that could be good for me. But...who knows-I can move on to something better!
DeleteForget the outside voices and listen to the one from your heart... that's the only one that really matters.
ReplyDeleteThanks! It's true!
DeleteGreat post, my husband and I have had the "how did we end up with this life?" conversation several times over the years. I just met a running store owner last week who used to have a corporate job, and packed it all in to work, then buy the running store. I wish you luck with your decision!
ReplyDeleteThat would be a dream come true in my world! To connect other runners with one another and with great products. Yup, I could live with that.
DeleteGood luck making those tough decisions! I can definitely relate... my husband is doing his post doc right now, and is on the job market. The pressure is definitely on for a top notch research job, but we are trying to ensure that family would remain a top priority in our lives, not work. As a woman, the pressure is even worse, I'm sure- feeling pulled in so many different directions. I felt it just quitting my job to stay home, can't imagine being on the path to academia... do what's best for you! :)
ReplyDeleteOh wow, Laura, I had no idea. I knew there was a reason I like you (it is not an easy job to be married to an academic). There are certainly family-friendly positions available if you are willing to move to certain places. I went to a liberal arts college for undergrad and it was an amazing experience, but it was in rural PA with not much happening. Good luck to him and keep me posted!
DeleteI definitely understand how you feel. I am finishing up my PhD and trying to decide what to do next. Within academia, I think you get a lot of pressure to stay. Faculty see you doing well and think you would be a great asset to the environment. I have had quite a few people tell me I should stay in academia, and I am not sure if it is right for me too. Even though you have put in a lot of time with your post-doc and other training, I think no matter what direction you go in you will have great experiences to talk about -- and that is what is important. You will have your own ideas to bring to the table. Do what is best for you and make sure YOU are truly happy!
ReplyDeleteGood luck deciding what you decide to do! And good luck finishing up. It is daunting to think about how to equate all those years of grad school to real work experience, but I am sure I can do it.
DeleteI just found your blog and this post resonates with me -- am second year into a postdoctoral fellowship. Don't stress to much about having all the answers to this right now. From my experience, which path you should choose will become clearer and clearer as time progresses. Be okay with not knowing the next step...so hard to do but so liberating. Trust in the process Amy.
ReplyDelete